Welcome, both returnees and newcomers, to the second monthly installment of the Read Your Own Library! Challenge. First things first. I cannot believe that I forgot to announce in last month's post WHICH LEVEL OF MY OWN CHALLENGE I was signing on for! So let me rectify that right now. The whole reason I started this challenge is because I needed to go into total BIBLIO REHAB, as I probably already own more books than I'll read in my lifetime. And though I have bought books since the challenge first began, I was a good girl, fulfilled my own requirements, and read not one but two of the books I already owned in October before buying any more. So, allow me now to bestow upon myself the badge for my chosen level of book recovery.
Now then, on to a review of the book to which I originally committed myself at the beginning of the challenge last month, Stuart Little. Oh, dear. After a lifetime of absolutely adoring Charlotte's Web by E.B. White, I found his tale of the bizarre mouse born to a family of humans very disappointing. My apologies here and now to all those who love Stuart as much as I love Charlotte, but I REALLY disliked this book.
I don't mean to say that I hated everything about it. It had some charming vignettes, like Stuart becoming the captain of a toy sailboat. But it had no narrative arc, told no unified story, never explained how a human couple produced a mouse as their son, and had the least satisfying ending that I have read in years. Moreover, there was at least one scene that made me want to slap Stuart outright (it was during his first real date, for those who are curious to know to which scene I'm referring). Sorry, but overall, I prefer Beverly Cleary's Ralph Mouse and his motorcycle to Stuart Little's ridiculously invisible toy car any day.

So, for those returning to the challenge, did you finish the goal you set yourself last month? Give us a post telling us all about it. I'll be sure to e-mail you the code for the lovely badge you've earned yourself! And to our newbies, welcome! Tell us how you got into your current state of backlog, and what you plan to read this month. We're all anxious to cheer you on.
Read Your OWN Library! Challenge
1. | Bev@My Reader's Block | |
2. | Cat @ Tell Me A Story | |
3. | Lianne @ The Towering Pile | |
4. | Bean |
(Cannot add links: Registration/trial expired)
Just entered my link...although it doesn't seem to be appearing. Ready for my next adventure...
ReplyDeleteNow it says that there's a link...but not showing up. Here's my link: http://myreadersblock.blogspot.com/2011/10/question-of-proof-review.html
ReplyDeleteif anyone would like to visit.
Oh...and I love the idea of your Victory Garden. If I were to have one, the very first seed planted would have been Tristram Shandy--which I FINALLY finished this past spring. It's been on my shelf for over 20 years and this was my third attempt to read the thing. Third time's a charm and all that. :-)
ReplyDeleteSorry about that, Bev; got the linky squared away now. Tristram Shandy...I still haven't even gotten around to trying and failing at that one yet. :)
ReplyDeleteI am told by a Shandy fan-boy (my good friend & an 18th C scholar) that it takes some of us lesser beings about three actual readings (not attempts) before we really like Tristram. I told him that I wasn't sure I wanted to invest that much time on him. :-)
ReplyDeleteMy next Victory Garden plant may be A Tale of Two Cities. I'm contemplating that one for the Back to the Classics Challenge.
The more I think about your Victory Garden, the more I like it. Might I borrow your idea (with proper kudos, of course!)?
ReplyDeleteBev, feel free! I was actually kind of hoping that the idea would catch on when I created it, and that I would see them start popping up elsewhere, because I figured I could NOT be the only pathological reader who has ever been temporarily beaten by a book.
ReplyDeleteI did it! Posted here: http://myreadersblock.blogspot.com/p/bevs-victory-garden.html
ReplyDeleteHave added mine. Not sure what's coming up next.
ReplyDeleteI guess I kind of misunderstood the instructions last month, so for the October post I said what I planned to read in November. So I guess I'll just continue on like this. I chose The Shining by Stephen King for November, and I'm almost done it, so I'll add my link in a few days when my review is up.
ReplyDeleteI'm loving this challenge! It's really keeping me motivated! Especially since I'm knocking a chunkster like The Shining off my list already. :)
Apparently I confused myself. :) I didn't post a link last time because I missed the cut-off date. So I guess I'm just starting a month behind and will now post my starting-the-challenge link.
ReplyDeleteI sooooo agree with everything you say about Stuart Little. Charlotte's Web was my favorite book as a kid, and though I have to say I "like" Stuart little, my read of it a few months ago left me scratching my head. And I too got irritated by Stuart during the date. I was frankly puzzled by this one. :D But I remember loving it as a kid! I have a feeling I read the first half as a kid and just never read the rest. :P
ReplyDelete